The Women of Arabia Wore Shalwar Kameez in the 7th Century

The Women of Arabia

I am a Hijabi and have been since I was 10. Over the years I’ve come to accept the judgmental stares and even embraced them to a certain extent.  People often have preconceived notions about Hijabis many of which would be proven false if they actually get to know the person underneath that head wrap.

This article is not about people judging me based on the fact I wear a scarf. It is about the baseless assumptions they make from my external appearance. Sadly, most of these people are from my community, the South Asian community.

When they first look at me, I’ve come to the conclusion that this is their thinking process: Hijabi = Pakistani = Speaks Urdu.

I have come to realize that these unique people that I’ve encountered cannot seem to distinguish between religion, nationality or language. They seem to be convinced that all Indians are Hindu, that all Hijabis are Pakistani and that Muslims only speak Urdu.

I have had to endure excruciating conversations trying to prove that the above are merely generalizations. Below is a sample of such conversation. It’s a compilation of all the encounters I’ve had with a stereotyping South Asian aunty/uncle. My responses are mostly my real replies, others which I wish I had said or was thinking in my head.

Aunty: Assalamalaikum Beta, kaise hain aap? (How are you in Urdu)

Me: Alaikumsalam Aunty. Sorry, but I don’t speak Urdu.

Aunty: But you are Muslim, No? (Points to my Hijab)

Me: Yes I am Muslim, but my mother tongue is Tamil.

Aunty: How is that possible?? How can you be a Muslim and not know Urdu???

Me: The Quran is in Arabic, the Prophet did not know Urdu, is he not a Muslim as well??

Aunty: You speak Tamil…so you are Sri Lankan?

Me: No I am Tamilian, from Tamil Nadu, in India.

Aunty: Oh India, so you are Hindu?

Me: No, Indian is my nationality and Islam is my religion. So I can come from India AND be a Muslim.

Aunty: So if you are Indian, you must speak Hindi?

Me: India has over 100 spoken languages of which they arbitrarily chose two as their national languages: Hindi and English. There is an entire state dedicated to the Tamil Language and culture, Tamil Nadu, which literally means Tamil Country! So NO, being Indian doesn’t necessarily mean I speak Hindi.

Aunty: Let me get this straight. You are an Indian, but you aren’t a Hindu or speak Hindi. You are a Muslim but not from Pakistan or speak Urdu. You speak Tamil but are not from Sri Lanka…(all this is too much for them to comprehend, so they usually just give up after this point).

I am not even kidding when I say that Pakistani Muslims have told me that I can’t be a Muslim because I don’t speak Urdu.

When I was a kid my mom and I used to go to religious gatherings in Thorncliffe Park. It is usually filled with Sri Lankan Muslims. At one specific gathering a Pakistani woman came to give a lecture and she noticed that my mom was wearing a sari underneath her burka. She gave my mom a lecture about how Muslims shouldn’t wear saris and wear shalwar kameez instead, because supposedly that’s what women wore at the time of the prophet.

WHAT THE FIDDLESTICKS?!?!?!?!

I wonder where on earth they came up with such claims. As far as I know, women at the time of the prophet wrapped themselves with any cloth they can find in no specific fashion as long as it maintained their modesty.

The problem with the people I have described above is that they intermingle religion and culture, which has proven to be a recipe for disaster. And my generation (anyone in their 20s) is fully aware of how difficult it can be to deal with this ‘problem’.

On top of climate change, depleting natural resources such as oil and water, and increasing poverty, this is another issue that our generation takes on. But hey no worries, we are equipped with technology, social media and the intellect to differentiate between religion and culture (I hope).

-Image courtesy of RickyAndria Photography

Editor's Note


Thank's so much for being a TC Reader! To continue bringing you more of the stories you love for free, our team needs your help. Will you make a small contribution? Every bit helps!

Give $15 Give Another Amount

Author

Shifana

Shifana

Born in Pattukottai, Tamil Nadu she came to Canada with her family when she was 8. Studied chemical engineering but somehow life put her in the IT sector, as they say, 'when life gives you lemonade, throw lemons at it!'. She is often (too often) asked the question: 'How can you speak Tamil but not be a Tamil?' Well, life is full of mysteries...

Read More Stores From Shifana...
Connect
Tags: ,

5 thoughts on “The Women of Arabia Wore Shalwar Kameez in the 7th Century

  1. Great piece! I really resonated with this piece as an Indian-Muslim who is of a darker skintone who is automatically pigeonholed as Tamil even though I speak Urdu. People are sometimes akin to stick to the narrow perceptions they concieve from the limited information they have or seek to have. It’s great for this piece to show the diversity and heterogeneity within the South Asian community. We are a complicated mileu of intersecting faiths, languages, ethnicities, cultures and nationalities.

    Thank you for this piece again! 🙂

  2. @d67af8de7b31c68c0992c9b33611df61:disqus
    Hi Thendral, thanks Thendral.. is your name really Thendral ? Do your parents watch Thendral.. mine do 😛 haha!

    @twitter-176516949:disqus
    Haha Anjum that reminds me of an incident from grade 10 French class..actually I don’t remember this but my friends often recall it in fits of laughter. My French teacher approached me and pointing to my skin asked why I was light coloured if I spoke Tamil (En Francais of course). My friends found this hilarious while I struggled to respond in French explaining how I can speak Tamil and be fair at the same time.
    It’s just a lack of knowledge and we can’t really blame them for making generalizations. It’s funny how you are the opposite of me, everyone assumes I speak Urdu and people assume you speak Tamil.
    Thanks for reading 🙂

    Well put and true indeed: “We are a complicated mileu of intersecting faiths, languages, ethnicities, cultures and nationalities.”

  3. Ha ha thanks for the article.  I find the viewpoints of this pakistani lady to be hilarious.   On the whole i find pakistanis to b eone of  the most judgemental and backwards people i come across but ironically believe themselves to be superior.  THis is especially yhte case in the uk where i live.  IT’s funny how pakistanis are lecturing tamil/sri lankan muslims on how to dress when they have so many isssues that they need to sort out first of all.  Atleast sri lankans/tamils living in western countries do not g around raping uderage girls or killing their woman/ girl child for the slightest reason.  As far as i am concerned sri lankan or tamil muslims are light years ahead in terms of their behaviour in comparison to pakistani muslims and infact it should be they who should be lecturing pakistani muslims on how to behave as proper muslims not the other way around.  I don’t know why the sri lankan muslims invited this price joker in the first place.

  4. LOL. As a guy who grew up with muslims from cuddalore, papanasam, chidambram, I always found Indian Tamil muslims very humble and cultural. Never heard them discriminate other religions or cultures. They love tamil language and had amazing family values. The pakistanis,bangladeshis I have found in Canada are really backward and have some weird sense of superiority complex as thirumaran puts it. Just ignore them.

Leave a Reply

More In Life